14/40 Non-Existence


The 77% Weekly

The 40/52 weeks-a-year, spiritual-religious newsletter 

14/40 From Rabbi Brian

Children, religion, and God.

My son, when he was 3-years-old saw a man standing on the top of a building and asked me, “Is that man God?” 


“I don’t think that’s God,” I replied. 


“Yes, I think it is God,” Emmett said. 


Was I to disagree? I didn’t know. 


Would it be wrong to tell him that the man standing on the roof was a repair-maintenance guy, and not God? Would it matter?


I am commonly asked a question that goes something like this:


Dear Rabbi Brian, I understand this idea of questioning God and having an adult relationship with God. I can get behind that. But how do I apply this notion to my children? I want to do the right thing. I want to give them some religious background. But what do I tell them?


Article Continues Below…

Rabbi Brian Zachary Mayer is the founder of Religion-Outside-The-Box.

After being ordained as a rabbi, he left mainstream congregational life to encourage people to find and be with (the) God (of their understanding) through podcasts, books, tweets, and internet-based seminars.  

His day job is teaching mathematics to Los Angeleno High School students. The rest of the time is with his family.

Like us on Facebook

Sign up for this Saturday’s Topic Talk.


The Bible: What you ought to have learned, but didn’t.


4/28. * Live at 11am EST / 8am PST. * Or any time later.

Sign up today and save $2!  Click for details.  


I’ll be the first to admit I’m not an expert at parenting. Although I’m working on it daily, I’m not there yet. My kids are young, and I’m still pretty new at this. (My brilliant friend Noa quips, “I was a great parent before I had kids.”)

Although I obtained one Masters in Religion and another Masters in Education with a concentration in the spiritual-religious development of adolescents, this doesn’t mean I’m an authority on the topic. Even when my children are older, I doubt I’ll be an expert. What I can tell you is this: nobody is an expert.


There are no longitudinal studies that give any solid advice for parents on this topic. Although a few studies have been conducted on the ‘typical’ development of God beliefs from childhood to adulthood, there’s nothing in academic literature that  advises us on how parenting or religious affiliation affect a child’s religious beliefs.


No one has a clue if having a Christmas tree or not having one, believing in the tooth-fairy or not, or having a Mormon neighbor have any correlation to a child’s ability to develop a healthy spiritual-religious life when they are older.  


Studies do suggest that having a strained relationship with a father can lead to a desire to delve into religion and that continual tragedy can mature one’s spiritual-religious growth – neither of which I would quite advocate as parenting strategies.   

This leads me to suggest to parents: you are the expert. It’s your child. You are your child’s guide. Do the best you can. Lead them with confidence not knowing what you are doing. 


Here are my general guidelines:

  • Be honest with your child. Tell them you don’t have all the answers, and that any answer must come from inside of them.
  • Allow your child to have different beliefs than you at different times in their life. They’ll go through stages. Don’t tell them what to believe. Instead, allow them to explore. Allow them to ask questions.
  • Be a model for them. Show them it’s OK to struggle with God beliefs. Tell them “not knowing” is fine.
  • Encourage them to ask other people what they think. Inspire them to ask other adults, “What do you think about God?”

For that matter, I encourage you to ask other adults what they think about God. (If you are bold enough, do it openly instead of hiding behind your child. Instead of saying, “Little Jimmy was wondering…” say “Jimmy and I were wondering…” Or better yet, say “I was wondering.” That’s real modeling.


I know as parents, we want only the best for our children. We want our kids to grow up and live in a world where they can clearly distinguish right from wrong, good from bad, God from non-God. We want certainty and solutions, but sometimes this is not possible. With regard to all the impossible questions, there are only different levels of comfort in the discomfort of unknowing.

The worst thing I or any other religious person can do is to undermine you as the foremost authority on your child’s religious development.
Spiritual-religious advice: Be the expert for the children in your life, model for them what a healthy spiritual-religious life is. 

With love,                                                                         Like me on Facebook

  Rabbi Brian

Rabbi Brian  

Support ROTB…

Schedule a monthly recurring donation to ROTB and receive a FREE DOWNLOAD “How To Deal With Impossible People.” 

$77 a month

$6.42 a month
($77 a year)

$3.34 a month

($1 an issue)



Or, make a one-time donation …






Donate Donate Donate Donate


I thank you. -Rb 

ROTB’s newsletter, website, and podcasts cost thousands of dollars to publish and maintain.  Please consider making a US tax-deductible contribution to help defray the costs. Details about donations to ROTB.

Share with a Friend


Also by Rabbi Brian

77% Weekly
Rabbi Brian

Go To Bed, Dad

Go To Bed, Dad.  It’s Tuesday night.  I’ve just come downstairs and entered the living room; Jane, Annie, and a beloved young friend, Calliope, are

Read More »
77% Weekly
Rabbi Brian

Kickstarter Book Launch

    Hello Beloved friend,   I don’t have an article for you this week. And, I’m sorry.   I’m working (mindfully, with compassion towards

Read More »

Because you want peace trust self-esteem love .