Broken Whole


It is Yom Kippur — the holiest day of the Jewish years. 

I’m in my backyard. In a tent. 



It’s my practice.


The dogs tell me and repeat: “Clear and present danger at the front door. Clear and present danger at the front door.” 


I unzip, go through the house, and find Tina with her toothy smile and twinkle in her eye. 


She likes to visit and share about her understanding of Jesus.


And, I’m glad to listen.


After all, we talk to children about the importance of having a growth mindset. 


I like to be open to learn.





Tina takes a color pamphlet from her well-worn bag. A photorealistic drawing of a longhaired, nearly pubescent boy sits on what appears to be a jungle floor, looking up as though he too is pondering the question hovering in large white letters above him—“Does God Care About You?”


She hands it to me.


“Tina, I have a question.”




“When you held this paper it asked me ‘Does God Care About You?’ Now that I’m holding it, I wonder if it’s now asking if God cares about you.”


“Oh God loves me,” Tina exclaims with the chuckle of a child.


“Me too,” I say. “God loves me, too.”


What is a religious salesperson to say when I proclaim to already have the product they are selling?






Tina starts up again: “I would like to read a piece of Scripture and hear your reaction to it. It’s Peter 5:6-7.”


I like how the numbers are in sequential order, five, six, seven.


She reads from the divinely misogynistic New World Translation (NWT).


Humble yourselves, therefore, under the mighty hand of God, so that he (SIC) may exalt you in due time, while you throw all your anxiety on him (SIC), because he (SIC) cares for you.


I didn’t know there was a scripture  about turning over our anxiety to God and that God in turn will redeem us from it.






I find comfort knowing that the authors of the Bible faced anxiety too.






The word anxiety seems a bit modern to my ear, so later I do a bit of research. The Greek word translated as anxiety is μέριμναν—merimna, which means divided or fractured.


That makes sense.


I’m reminded of the solution to posed by the third of most 12-step programs—when you face your μέριμναν—brokenness—you can feel more whole.






As I walk back to the tent I contemplate a quote from Rabbi Nachman of Breslov: “If you believe breaking is possible, believe fixing is possible.”






The moral of the story on this Yom Kippur: broken, divided, anxious, or fractured, we are nonetheless whole.








Fred Rogers told me that he liked me just as I am.

And I believed him.


Why not? I was a kid.

He sang about it. About him liking me “exactly and precisely,” “without a doubt or question” just as I am.


Why would he lie?





I’m about 15 years old. 

The last class period of the day is over. 

I am looking to hang with someone. 

Being with people helps me feel seen. Real.


So, I do a sweep of the 6th floor library looking.

None of my friends are there. 

So I exit to the stairwell and count each of the 42 steps up to the 8th floor. 


Don Sorell isn’t in the music office. 

Sometimes he and I chat.


In the future, after George Floyd, I’ll find a link for him—now Head of the Collegiate School Music Department—on the school website and we’ll reconnect a bit.


He’ll remind me that my dad had the Victor Hugo quote —”There is no force as powerful as an idea whose time has come”—on his business card.


He’ll also be the first person I know of to contract and die of COVID.


I meander into the art room. 

Sometimes I do homework there with friends. Or just goof around thinking about doing homework.


“Can I help you?” asks an attentive woman I do not know in the green canvas smock.


“Nah, just wandering. Meandering, actually,” I say.


She beams, “Would you like to try the still life the 4th grade class was just painting?”





Maybe it’s easier for children to believe someone likes us just as we are because they are closer to the age when people, hopefully got love for just being.


Adults are a bit more skeptical about messages of love.


Many adults, maybe even you, believe, “If you really got to know me, you wouldn’t still love me.”





The green smocked lady brings me over to a tableau of shoes on the table and pulls out a chair, inviting me to sit.


She tells me she’s a sub for the lower schoolers, and “wouldn’t you like to try your hand at a watercolor this afternoon?” 


Spellbound, I put down my backpack and start on a pencil outline on a 8.5 x 5.5 inch sheet of watercolor paper.





What if we allowed love in?


What if we stopped repeating and believing the terrible things we tell ourselves? 


What if we allowed ourselves to be as we were as children, lovable exactly as we are?





“I love it,” she says minutes later.


“You’re kidding.”


“No, the colors, the abstraction. It’s really quite good.”


I look at it. It looks nothing like the reality I see.

She is probably one of these “happy with everything in life” type people.

Or she is comparing my work to that of the little kids she worked with all day.






Could it be?





When I get into my office in the morning, I see someone doodled on a piece of paper with a red sharpie.


The clue to the artist’s identity isn’t that hard to figure out—they also left their shoes, their backpack, an empty bowl, and some candy wrappers.


Emmett likes to use my home-office set-up when I’m done for the day.


I sit back and enjoy the sketch—a fire-head with a large mustache, and big eyes.


I like it.


Is it empirically good? 

I dunno that.

But I know logic. I’m horrible biased. I like it because I like the artist.


And logic says IF I am able to love his art—however good or bad it is—just because you love him THEN I ought to be able to do the same for my art—or whatever else I do.





Frequently following the compliment—“your high school students must have loved you”—I am asked why I stopped teaching high school.


I explain, “I found a population more desperate for my cajoling into knowing they are loved.”

Then I pause, they usually look up, I make eye contact, and continue: “you.”





You might not believe me,  ____<insert your name here___>.

And, that’s ok.

You can even deny it.


But, Mr. Rogers and I still know it is true. You are loveable exactly as you are.



LIVE! Saturdays at 8am PT

Stream   LIVE :  ROTB site (here). Or on Facebook / YouTube

LIVE! Saturdays at 8am PT

Stream   LIVE :  ROTB site (here). Or on Facebook / YouTube

With love,
Rabbi Brian

——–LIVE! Saturdays at 8am PT
Stream   LIVE :  ROTB site (here). Or on Facebook / YouTube

Share with a Friend


Also by Rabbi Brian

77% Weekly
Rabbi Brian

It’s OK not to be OK

A startling discovery about 2024—this year has 53 Mondays, not the standard 52. 2019: 52 Mondays2020: 52 Mondays2021: 52 Mondays2022: 52 Mondays2023: 52 Mondays2024: 53

Read More »
77% Weekly
Rabbi Brian

A Story of Humanity

A Story of Humanity   I’m the 30-year-old assistant rabbi of Temple Judea — a congregation of a few thousand in Tarzana, California.   It’s my

Read More »