“I love you” x 3

77% Weekly Newsletter

“I love you” x 3

For reasons a team of psychoanalysts might have been able to crack, my dad couldn’t get the three-word phrase “I love you” to come out of his mouth.

I knew he loved us.

It’s just he couldn’t say it.

I rationalized that I didn’t need to hear those three words, but it hurt anyway.

This is the story about how I got my dad close enough to saying it.

And, that was enough.

✧✧✧

I take the red-eye flight from Los Angeles to New York, to visit.

Dad’s in the hospital.

Again.

It’s becoming more the rule than the exception that I stop at the hospital on the east side—Sloan Kettering—to visit him before going across town to see my mom and sister.

We don’t talk about it, but I can see it.

I know it.

Dad is dying.

✧✧✧

After I land, Mom tells me that Dad has a feeding tube or he’s intubated or something—I get a bit dissociated around medical stuff, so I don’t remember what it was—but bottom line, “he won’t be able to talk.”

“I’ll talk enough for both of us,” I say.

I walk in.

He’s awake.

In his eyes I see the same emotions I have—a dash of delight for seeing each other, atop exhaustion and deep grief.

I tease, “Ma said I should do most of the talking,”

He nods.

I put my backpack down, reach in it, and take out some papers.

“The kids made you some pictures, Pops,” I say, trying to keep it light. ”And I brought a roll of tape, all the way from California—so let’s say I put some art on the wall and decorate this place.”

I talk.

He gestures responses.

After about 30 minutes, he indicates that he has had enough and is going to close his eyes.

“Alright, buddy. You want me to come back in a little while—after you have a nap? Or do you want me to come back tomorrow?”

He moves his hand in a slow, shallow arc from side to side.

“That means tomorrow, yes?”

“Yes,” he nods.

“Alright, buddy, tomorrow,” I say, and I give him a kiss on the forehead.

✧✧✧

As I wrap my scarf around my neck and tuck it into my coat, I say, “Hey, Pops, I have three things I want to tell you.”

He looks at me.

The thing is, I don’t know what three things I am going to say.

But I’m not worried. The right words will follow. I’ve gotten myself into and out of situations like this before.

“Three things,” I repeat, stalling a moment as I hold up one finger and say, “First, I love you.”

We hold a moment of eye contact as I raise a second finger.

“Two,” I say, “I love you.”

Feels swell in my chest, and tears come to my eyes as I raise my third finger and say, “Three, I love you.”

As I pick up my bag, he waves to get my attention.

He looks at me and slowly raises one, then two, then three fingers—telling me that he loves me, too.

Rabbi Brian Doesn’t Understand

In the 18th century, in Hannipol, a small district of Khmelnytskyi Oblast, in present-day western Ukraine, there was a rabbi known as Reb Zusya. Zusya, a pious man, taught about humility and had a strange habit of referring to himself in the third person. Instead of saying, “I am hungry,” or “I don’t understand,” he would say, “Zusya is hungry,”

Read More »

Travesty

I rewind the etymology podcast 15 seconds because I missed the details about the origin of the word travesty. I want to listen again—more closely—so I learn it, so I can recall it later in conversation… because if I tell you how travesty—from “traverse” and “clothing”—came to mean “shockingly unfair,” you’ll think I’m smart. Lost in that thought, I suddenly

Read More »

The Soup We Are In

Most of the time, even when we don’t really need to be rushing (and sometimes without realizing we are rushing) a really large percentage of us rush anyhow. Seems we are angled forward, always striving to get ahead. I get it. It’s the soup we are in. Our society conflates productivity, hurriedness, and worth. We take on the flavors around

Read More »
77% Weekly Newsletter
77% Weekly Newsletter